Hello I propose a new approach for the T7 in place of the garbage rules :
We have two types of players in the guild:
The big guns, the people who can score very high in phases 1 and 4
The little fishes, the others players.
In each raids we have something like 30+/- 5 players who participate.
For the phase 1, I propose that all the big guns (~7 players) use the trash rules (so if we destroy the beast really easily they will all have a reward), when they all did, one of them send 1 team. He said in the chat "I go" when his team is out he said "I have finish". If the phase is not over the next player go. Until the phase is over.
This way we don't lose damages.
For the phase 2 and 3, all the little fishes at the same time, if they want they can't finish either of the phase by themselves, send 1 team by phase, when they have finish they said "I have finish". When all the little fishes have send one team (Jim or Germinoule decide when this is good), we do like the phase 1: one big gun by one until the phase is over.
For the phase 4: everybody send what he wants and we hope to defeat the Rancor.
I think that is a better way to not lose many damages, like in the last raid. With 10 players expel from the guild and some big guns we need to have a better strategy or to recruit some big guns.
What do you think?